So far seems great, I ordered two of them and they pull out and retract well. Time will tell for these, so I'll have to come back and update in a year. Seems like a newer product, mine was made in August and had SN 228, so they've only made a couple hundred so far. If these last at least two years I'll be happy with them. Look forward to actually using them for a while, hopefully, you're allowed to edit reviews here. So far I'd recommend them based on just my cursory opinion and a few minutes of testing. 4* for now, 5* if they are still working well in a year.
Doris 
